In the past 2 years since you last played, there's been a reasonable amount of development in golf ball technology. Some of the best name brand high end balls are still out there under the same names, (Titleist Pro-V series, Bridgestone B330 series, Srixon high end balls), but what has grown almost exponentially in the market is the selection of middle level balls like the Titleist NXT or the Bridgestone e5 and e6 balls.
My point is, it's all going to depend on your game and finding what works best for you. I've known low handicap players who had very different games from one another and these days, would most suitably use very different balls.
If you hit it real long off the tee, versus shorter, but very accurately, your considerations are going to be different.
The search is half the fun.
Iíve had a good day when I donít fall out of the cart.